February 21, 2008

Carbon Tax

The carbon tax is not well-thought out. Raising the price of fuel by adding another tax won't make others think twice about driving. Why is that?
  • Well, the convenience and time-saving elements of owning and using your own vehicle outweighs the extra few dollars it takes to fill up on fuel.
  • With the steep gas prices in recent times, some have driven less, but no one I know has changed their habits by much (although every little bit does help).
  • If you already tend to be a transit user, that practice will continue, but if not... nothing will change your mind about that "loser cruiser"... yes, that great big smelly bus.
  • If you live outside the Vancouver Lower Mainland, you do not benefit because transit systems in rural areas aren't as efficient. Think of places like Prince Rupert, Boston Bar, Revelstoke, Trail, etc.. There are no "alternative" forms of transportation, especially if the bus runs only once per hour, on a limited route during weekends, or if you live on a farm and need the truck to travel everywhere.
  • I am already imagining BC using the tax to "buy" environmental credits to lower their rating on pollution... rather than actually solving the REAL environmental issues here.
Also... if they are taxing carbon pollutants, might as well tax plastics too, as well as toxic materials like construction materials, liquid cleaners, and pesticides. Aren't all pollutants made equal anyway? Why only tax the fuel for transportation? Pollutants, whether in the air or in the ground are harmful to the environment, plants, animals, and humans.

It is the cynicism in me that is talking... but I don't see how the carbon tax can fight pollution, as it will NOT affect human behaviour.

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

especially when bus prices continue to rise almost every other year. if they had more accesable transit outside of vancouver at a cheaper price then and only then would people use it even more.

The reason why the carbon tax is chosen is that it's good PR plus getting drivers is easier than going after big business. Plus the burning of oil is our largest pollutant. I actually like the tax if it DOES NOT go to carbon credits.... but knowing the government this is what will happen. great rant win. wgbc is out